Stock Market Guides sends up to ten US stock picks a week for $49 a month or $397 a year. Each exits at a target or time limit, with no stop in its rules, and its 79.4% return is a backtest. The Trade Desk, $199 a year, sets the stop before the week, adds forex, gold and oil, and publishes every loss.

Stock Market Guides is a US research service built on backtests. Its home page puts it simply: its software looks for stock and option trade setups, analyzes how similar setups performed in the past, and sends you real-time alerts
. There are three paid services: Stock Investing (holds of three months and up), Swing Trading (stocks, one week to one month) and Option Trading. This page is about the Swing Trading Service, the one WallStreetZen put first in its list of the best swing trading alert services, last updated 5 November 2026.
The Swing Trading Service gives you two things. A DIY scanner that finds chart patterns, indicator signals and candlestick patterns, and shows how each setup did in backtests on that stock. And swing trade picks, where the scanner chooses for you: We send out up to ten stock picks per week with our swing trading service. Some weeks there might be less.
Its FAQ says both are about stocks: Our Swing Trading Scanner and Swing Trading Picks are both focused on stocks.
the ticker symbol, when to buy it, and when to sell it, plus the strategy’s backtested wins, losses and return.
Most times this occurs within a half hour after the market opens.Pre-Market Picks come before the open.
its profit target or time limit (whichever comes first).
You can also set up a profit target and stop loss if you want.It links its own stop loss and take profit calculator to help.
That last point is the biggest difference from how I run the Desk. A time limit tells you when to leave. A stop tells you how much you can lose before you enter. The worked example below shows why that matters for position size.
These are the prices on its own service pages, read on 9 November 2026, with the Desk alongside.
| Plan | Month | Year | Per day |
|---|---|---|---|
| SMG Swing Trading | $49 | $397 | about $1.09 |
| SMG Stock Investing | $29 | $197 | about 54¢ |
| SMG Option Trading | $69 | $575 | about $1.58 |
| SMG all three services | $95 | $675 | about $1.85 |
| RB Trade Desk, letters included | $29 | $199 | about 55¢ |
SMG is Stock Market Guides. Per day is the yearly price divided by 365. The Desk’s $199 is 20% off its $249 list. Yearly prices are what each SMG page shows with its Yearly toggle on.
One thing to know before you compare lists: WallStreetZen says subscriptions start at just $29 per month
. That is true, but $29 buys the Stock Investing Service, for long holds. The swing alerts it ranked first are $49 a month. Paid monthly for a year, that is $588.
It is a working service, and on one point it is more honest than most: it does not dress its backtests up as live results. Under its swing figures it prints this performance information is not based on live trades, but on backtests, which have important limitations
. Its disclaimer goes further and says backtests do not account for slippage or fees, and carry a risk of curve fitting.
Here are the swing figures it publishes, and one sum I ran on them.
| Swing Trade Picks, backtest results | As published |
|---|---|
| Wins | 168,968 |
| Losses | 108,404 |
| Avg. annualised return | 79.4% |
| Win rate (my sum: 168,968 of 277,372) | 60.9% |
From stockmarketguides.com/swing-trading-service, read 9 Nov 2026. The win rate is my division of its own two figures, not a number it states.
That 60.9% fits its own FAQ, which says the win percentage on many of our trade alerts is 55% or 60%
. What I could not find on its service pages is a list of the live picks it actually sent, with the result of each. That is the question to ask any alert service: not how the strategy tested, but what happened to the trades it sent you last month.
| Stock Market Guides (Swing) | Trade Desk | |
|---|---|---|
| Markets | US stocks; options are a separate $69 a month service | Stocks, forex, gold, silver, oil, indices and crypto |
| When trades are sent | Up to ten picks a week, mostly in the first half hour after the US open | The week’s plan before the Sunday open, alerts when a level hits |
| Stop loss | Not in the rules; you can set your own | Published with every setup, before the trigger |
| Exit | Profit target or time limit, whichever comes first | Stop or scale-out targets |
| Alerts | Email, or text to US numbers only | Push and email, no daily cap |
| Record | Backtest results; says they are not live trades | Every closed live trade, losers included, on /track-record |
| Price | $49 a month or $397 a year | $29 a month, or $199 a year against $249 list |
| Free option | Free scanner without the backtest history, free email list | Free section: the record, guides, market brief and calendar, email only |
Stock Market Guides details from its own pages, read 9 Nov 2026. Desk details from the Desk’s home page.
You are never committed to the service for any longer than the current period you paid for.
If you only trade US stocks, like a quantitative approach and want plenty of ideas to choose from, it is a fair choice. If you want a stop on every trade, markets beyond US stocks, or a live record to judge it by, read on.
The free letter walks through the method, the markets and the weeks that matter.
Take a $10,000 account and a rule of risking 1% a trade, $100. A stock is bought at $50.00. These figures are an illustration, not a real pick from either service.
| Step | Stop at $46 | Time limit only |
|---|---|---|
| Risk per share | $4.00 | Unknown |
| Shares for $100 risk | 25 | Cannot size it |
| Falls to $40 before the limit | Out at $46: −$100 | 25 shares: −$250 |
| Loss as % of account | 1% | 2.5% |
Shares = $100 ÷ ($50 − $46). A gap through the stop can fill worse than $46.
With a stop you know the worst case before you press buy, so you can size the trade. With a time limit only, the loss is whatever the price is when the clock runs out. You can add your own stop to a Stock Market Guides pick, but then you are trading your rule, not the one its backtest tested. For how I place stops, see how to set a stop loss for swing trading.
Not that I could find. Its service pages and its full FAQ list, read on 9 November 2026, do not mention a trial or a money-back guarantee. What it does have is a free scanner, though You won’t be able to see the historical performance of each scan result
without the paid service, and a free email list. You can cancel from your account page at any time.
The Desk has no trial either. Instead the free section stays free: the full record, the guides and the news calendar, with an email and no card. You can judge the work before you pay for it.
People search for both. I could not open either from here, as both refused the request, so this page quotes neither, and I would not trust a summary that claims to. When you read those threads, check three things:
Every Sunday: analysed swing setups across stocks, forex, gold, silver, oil and indices with the exact entry, stop and target, push and email alerts when a level hits, and the paid Substack letters.
Get the annual, 20% off →Its Swing Trading Service is $49 a month or $397 a year on its own site, checked 9 November 2026. The $29 a month price some lists quote is its Stock Investing Service, for holds of three months and up. The Option Trading Service is $69 a month or $575 a year, and all three together are $95 a month or $675 a year.
It is a working US service that is open about its numbers: its site says the 79.4% average annualized return is from backtests, not live trades, and its disclaimer lists the limits of backtests. What it does not publish on its service pages is a live record of the picks it sent.
Not in the trade rules. Its FAQ says a trade ends at its profit target or time limit, whichever comes first, and that you can also set up a profit target and stop loss if you want. The Trade Desk publishes the stop with every setup.
Its service pages and FAQ, read on 9 November 2026, do not mention one. It has a free scanner that hides the backtest history and a free email list, and its FAQ says you can cancel any time.
Its disclaimer says the service is published for individuals residing in the United States, and its FAQ says text alerts only go to US phone numbers, so outside the US alerts come by email.
Educational analysis, not financial advice. Trading carries a risk of loss, and past results, live or backtested, do not promise future ones. Stock Market Guides is a separate company with no link to RB Trading.