tradedesk.rbtrading.site / guides / mindful trader alternative

Mindful Trader vs the Trade Desk: two swing services, side by side

A live record, not a back test: the Trade Desk publishes every trade, losers included: 169 closed trades since 14 Nov 2025, 99 of them losers, +33.1R in total, each graded in R against the stop published before the fill. Both are swing services, so this is a close comparison. Mindful Trader sends US stock and options swing trades that it says typically last about a week, for $47 a month. The Trade Desk publishes weekly setups across stocks, forex, gold and crypto with the stop and target, for $29 a month or $199 a year, and keeps that record public, with a free section you can open with an email and no card.

By RB Trading · Updated 20 Oct 2026 · Mindful Trader facts checked on its own site on 20 Oct 2026 · Educational analysis, not financial advice

What each one sends

Mindful Trader’s sign-up page (checked 20 Oct 2026) describes stock picks and options picks, usually posted near the open at 6:30am Pacific, with commentary by email: 1 to 3 picks on typical days, and some weeks none at all. It is priced at $47 per month, billed monthly, and says you can discontinue at any time. Its swing trades page says the trades "typically last about a week on average", and its example page says each pick gives the ticker, the price paid, the profit exit and the stop-loss, and when the trade will be closed if neither is hit. Its site points to a sample of live trading results and a 20-year back test.

The Trade Desk publishes its board on Sunday: swing setups in large-cap stocks and crypto, forex and metals levels, a short squeeze screen, and mid-week Vol Entries, each with an entry, a stop and a target. Alerts fire on those levels by push and email, and the paid Substack letters explain the reasoning three times a week.

Holding period

"About a week" against the Desk's record: the median hold across 169 closed trades is 13 days, with most between six days and a month. If you want trades that resolve inside a week, that difference matters. If you want fewer decisions and room for a trade to work, a two-week median is the slower pace.

Bar chart of holding periods on the Trade Desk record: median 13 days, most trades held between 6 and 30 days
From the record: how long Desk trades were actually held. Median 13 days.
Mindful TraderTrade Desk
MarketsUS stocks and optionsStocks, forex, gold and metals, crypto, squeeze names
Typical holdAbout a week, by its own descriptionMedian 13 days on the published record
Price$47 a month, billed monthly$29 a month, or $199 a year with 20% off the annual
DeliveryMorning posts and emailApp, push and email alerts, Substack letters
RecordSample of live results and a back testEvery closed trade with entry, stop, exit and R

Mindful Trader details from its own site, checked 20 Oct 2026. Trade Desk figures from the published record.

A Desk trade, all the way through

Here is what one Desk swing setup looks like when it closes. Microsoft was called on the 12 July 2026 board with the entry at $385, the stop at $352 and the target at $481. It filled the next day and hit the target on 3 August: +2.91R, graded against the stop that was published before the fill.

The closed MSFT long on an R ladder: entry 385, stop 352, target 481 hit for +2.91R
From the record: the MSFT setup from the 12 July board, three weeks from fill to target.

Whichever you choose, run the four checks in best swing trade alert services on a closed trade from last month. A service that shows you its losers willingly is usually the one worth paying.

This week’s setups are already mapped

Every Sunday before the open: analysed swing setups across stocks, forex, gold and crypto with the exact entry, stop and target, an alert when one triggers, the live dashboard and the paid Substack letters.

169 trades · 99 losers shown · +33.1R see the full record → Get this week’s setups →
$29/mo · or $199/yr, 20% off the annual · paid Substack letters included · cancel anytime
Not ready to pay? Open the free section first: the full record, the guides and the news calendar, email only, no card. Members pay on Substack, then open the Desk with the same email.

FAQ

What is a good Mindful Trader alternative?

Another swing service that publishes stops and grades closed trades. The Trade Desk covers stocks, forex, gold and crypto with a public record in R; check which markets and holding period suit you.

How much does Mindful Trader cost compared with the Trade Desk?

Mindful Trader lists $47 a month, billed monthly (checked 20 Oct 2026). The Trade Desk is $29 a month, or $199 a year with 20% off the annual.

Which one holds trades longer?

Mindful Trader describes trades that typically last about a week. The Trade Desk record has a median hold of 13 days.

Does the Trade Desk trade options?

No. The setups are in stocks, forex, metals and crypto, quoted as price levels with a stop and target.

Keep readingBest swing trade alert services · Swing vs day trading · The published record · All guides